How New York City Got Its Juicy Nickname “The Big Apple” — And What It Means To The World

By Helen Johnson  

In the summer of 2016, a dermatologist in Boca Raton noticed something peculiar. Three patients, all successful women in their 40s, all with breast implants, had come to her with the same constellation of symptoms: unexplained rashes, joint pain, and a fatigue so profound they struggled to get through their spin classes.

What struck her wasn't their complaints, but what happened when she suggested their implants might be the cause. "Their reactions weren't relief," she recalls. "It was terror, like I'd told them they needed to cut off a limb."

This dermatologist had stumbled onto a medical mystery that would eventually connect thousands of women across the world. Because here's the uncomfortable truth about breast implants: the very thing millions of women choose to feel more confident, more desirable, more themselves might be making them profoundly sick. And what's even more surprising? The medical establishment still isn't entirely sure why.

The Confidence Trap

Consider Jessica Matthews (not her real name), a 34-year-old marketing executive who got implants after breastfeeding left her feeling "less feminine." For three years, she loved her new silhouette, until the migraines started. Then the brain fog. Then the morning she couldn't remember her assistant's name. "I spent $8,000 to feel beautiful," she says, "and wound up feeling like I had early-onset Alzheimer's."

Jessica's story follows a pattern researchers are only beginning to understand. When Dr. Robert Whitfield, a Texas plastic surgeon, began tracking 1,200 of his explant patients, he found something startling: 89% reported significant improvement in at least three "mystery" symptoms post-removal. The kicker? Only 7% had sought removal due to health concerns, most simply wanted smaller breasts.

The Body's Silent Rebellion

Now meet what may be the most misunderstood tissue in human anatomy: the capsule. This scar tissue forms naturally around implants as the body tries to wall off what it perceives as a foreign invader. In some women, this biological quarantine goes horribly wrong.

Dr. Lu-Jean Feng, a Cleveland surgeon who's performed over 3,000 explants, shows me a photo that makes my stomach clench: a silicone implant encased in scar tissue so thick it resembles a baseball. "This is what happens when the body says 'no' but the patient keeps saying 'yes,'" she explains. The frightening part? Many women with severe capsular contracture report no pain, their brains have literally rewritten their pain perception to preserve their self-image.

The Instagram Epidemic

Here's where the story takes a distinctly modern turn. In 2017, a Tennessee hairdresser named Karissa Pukas created a Facebook group for women questioning their implants. Within 18 months, it had 80,000 members. Today, #BreastImplantIllness has over 500,000 Instagram posts, a grassroots medical movement unfolding in real time.

What's fascinating isn't just the volume of cases, but their eerie similarity. Scroll through the hashtag and you'll find the same symptoms reported by a yoga instructor in Sydney and a rancher in Alberta:

• Crushing fatigue that mimics chronic fatigue syndrome
• "Autoimmune roulette" where patients test positive for multiple diseases
• A metallic taste some describe as "licking a battery"

The medical establishment remains skeptical—without a diagnostic test, BII can't be "proven."  Sometimes the absence of evidence isn't evidence of absence. Sometimes it just means we're asking the wrong questions.

The Liberation Paradox

Which brings us to the most surprising finding of all. When researchers at UT Southwestern interviewed 100 women post-explant, they expected regret. What they found was euphoria.

"I thought I'd miss them," admits Claire, 38, showing me a photo of her post-explant torso. "But when I saw my real body in the mirror for the first time in 12 years, I sobbed. Not because it was ugly. Because it was mine."

This might be the ultimate twist: that in our quest to "fix" ourselves, we often lose something more precious, the unmediated experience of being at home in our own skin. And that sometimes, the most radical act of self-care isn't addition, but subtraction.

The question we're left with isn't just about breast implants. It's about all the ways we alter ourselves to meet invisible standards, and what happens when we dare to question whether those standards were ever ours to begin with.